Ben Wade: Kid, I wouldn't last five minutes leading an outfit like that if I wasn't as rotten as hell. Dazu braucht er einige Männer und Evans erklärt sich für 200 Dollar bereit, die Gruppe zu begleiten. I won't downvote your opinion, only disagree with it. Then, at the last minute Wade saves the farmer’s life by risking his life to stand between the farmer and the gang. As the train begins to advance, Ben whistles to his horse and the horse follows the train. Favorite Answer. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Evans agrees to help escort Wade to a prison train (the 3:10 to Yuma) for a $200 reward. This song was played in the end of the film.Original title: "The 3:10 to Yuma"Composed by Marco Beltrami. The usual spoiler disclaimer verbiage … Its just fun to him. I think you know that. Todeszug nach Yuma (Originaltitel: 3:10 to Yuma) ist ein US-amerikanischer Western von James Mangold aus dem Jahr 2007. Relevance. It's not a spinning top. Unfortunately, it has an ending is so utterly implausible and ridiculous, relying on a ludicrous shoot-out where all of a sudden no-one can apparently hit a cow's arse with a banjo and a final scene that is so preposterously thought out that I could hardly believe it, that I almost feel … Zähl bis drei und bete (Originaltitel: 3:10 to Yuma) ist ein Schwarz-Weiß-Western des Regisseurs Delmer Daves aus dem Jahr 1957. In the original 1957 version of 3:10 to Yuma, the movie ends with Ben Wade (Glenn Ford) and the farmer (Van Heflin) going through the streets of town as the gang shoots at them. Van Heflin basically reprises his Shane role (and I … Ben Wade: I saved myself. Addresses are not passed on to any third party, and are used solely for direct communication from this site. I think I saw pretty clearly what Crowe's motivations were for turning on his crew and I liked his character more for it. Evans's son William (Logan … 3:10 to Yuma (1957 original recipe) is a case study in purely presenting the story of a good man confronted with the opportunity to finally prove his worth. Ending / spoiler for 3:10 to Yuma (2007), plus mistakes, quotes, trivia and more. The moment itself is fully about this new relationship with the rancher and what it's allowed Crowe to feel about himself and the rest of the world. as something he couldn't allow to stand. Wade's gang inflicts casualties on the guards, but Wade is successfully transported to Evans' ranch, where he is to wait for an hour while his gang follows a decoy wagon. After the movie cut a couple of times, Nez was shown walking up, throwing Wade's gun belt to Campos, who then threw it to Charlie Prince. Heflin's Evans is honest, almost saintly; but ultimately filling out his life with dullness and too much of a safe approach. Dan Evans (Christian Bale) is awoken by someone setting his barn on fire. You got him on the train." Close. From the beginning, we're given the notion that Crowe's character is committing robberies not because he needs to but moreso because he wants to. With Glenn Ford, Van Heflin, Felicia Farr, Leora Dana. Will disagree with on you Yuma though. 3 10 to Yuma Soundtrack film müziği3:10 to Yuma Original Motion Picture Soundtrack.Music by Marco Beltrami. And, am I imagining it, or was Crowe actually channeling Glenn Ford in the original. From making the run to taking out at least one of his guys along the way. There not a bad story in this collection. Ben Wade: Why should I? The movie opens late one night on the Evans family’s ranch (which is out in the middle of nowhere). When Dan told him the real story about his leg and his family he wanted to see Dan succeed so he decided to help him. THE OLD WEST. We already saw how disposable that gang is to him. William points his gun at Ben but doesn't shoot. The original 1957 version of 3:10 To Yuma—one of the first film adaptations of an Elmore Leonard story, alongside 1957's The Tall T—is a typical psychological Western, a lean, rangy black-and-white film as much about what its protagonists are thinking as what they're actually doing. I think it was because not only did he grew to respect him but also started to like him as well. And I think he saw the shooting of his captor in the back and the failure to stop firing when he shouted "no!" And once he'd made that decision they all had to die because he'd have been shot by one of the others once he shot at Prince. He tells Bale as much in one of the final scenes. William Evans: You saved us from those Indians. Directed by Delmer Daves. But ya gotta start building up your human empathy codes, cuz they're letting ya down. I'd also like to add also that both of Ben Wade's parents abandoned him. Russell Crowe and Christian Bale are both excellent in their characters. Plus, he knows he's going to escape from Yuma prison. Unsurprisingly, given its source, the film's plot is extremely simple, unconcerned with the need for a large cast of characters and complicated story lines. I'm not much of a Glenn Ford fan, even if he was in Gilda, but he was damn charming in this. I think it was a little bit of both, but what are you guys thought? 3:10 to Yuma, set in late nineteenth-century Arizona, tells the story of Dan Evans (Christian Bale), a rancher struggling to make ends meet. Also no I don't think the turn of Ben Wade on his men came out of nowhere. Cookies help us deliver our Services. It foreshadows how Charlie ruins something deeper than just killing for money that Wade cares about just like at the end of the movie. After Evans was shot near the end of the movie, Ben Wade jumped out of the train to look at him. Do you guys think it was out of revenge for killing Bale because he came to respect him or does he know they were gonna betray him someday anyway? Commentator: James Mangold (director) 1.He assumes the first question we might have for him regarding this film is “why” make a remake at all? 26. He easily kills that guy at the beginning. Ben Wade: If I had a gun in them tunnels, I would have used it on you. Rose and I went to see the remake of 3:10 to Yuma over the weekend after viewing the original 1957 version earlier in the week. Let's talk that 3:10 to Yuma (2007) ending. Primary Menu. Typical Elmore Leonard. Ben gets on the train out of respect for Dan, what he believed in and because he accomplished the task of getting Ben to the train. Broke small-time rancher Dan Evans is hired by the stagecoach line to put big-time captured outlaw leader Ben Wade on the 3:10 train to Yuma but Wade's gang tries to free him. Last year's Magnificent Seven remake is about the most boring movie I saw in theatres in 2016. Todeszug nach Yuma ist allerdings d… Der Film ist eine Neuverfilmung des Westernklassikers Zähl bis drei und bete mit Glenn Ford und Van Heflin aus dem Jahr 1957. William Evans: Call 'em off. Ben Foster's character has seen this. It was bad sport, and I'm guessing Bale's character was one of very few authentic people Ben ever met, unlike his own crew, who were followers that broke the rules in the end anyways, and did their own thing. It opens straight into the central action, with a stagecoach robbery gone wrong, … Although we enjoyed the remake, we both liked the original version better. He was the only reason they made it to the train in the first place. Although the movie was set a few years after the Civil War, the train was equipped with modern automatic couplers. Movies get made to tell stories about humans. William Evans: You got us through the tunnels. First of all, I love the movie, but what are you guys theory on the ending? Separate from membership, this is to get updates about mistakes in recent releases. That's the character you're watching have an emotional response to his new rancher pal getting smoked. Based on Elmore Leonard's eponymous 1953 short story, James Mangold's 2007 adaptation stays true to the original premise, only the climax is much darker and bloodier. He sees that he's a good family man who stands for something, which he seems to admire, and wants Bale to succeed so he can impress his son and get his farm back with the bounty money. You can unsubscribe at any time. And by the time they reach their destination, Crowe really likes Bale. William Evans: Because you're not all bad. Butterfield, ein hoher Mitarbeiter der Eisenbahngesellschaft, will ihn nach Contention bringen, wo dieser mit dem 3:10-Uhr-Zug zum Bundesgerichtshof in Yuma fahren soll. 3:10 TO YUMA (2007) NOTE: This spoiler was submitted by Caboose. Contact me | Privacy policy | Join the mailing list | Links. Das Drehbuch schrieben Halsted Welles, Michael Brandt und Derek Haas. As tough as Ben was it was clear he wasn't a heartless killer. Archived. Do you guys think it was out of … Great stories. To make him turn on his friends? Both versions of 3:10 to Yuma, however, are worth seeing I think (and then, with me, it's on to catch up with the FX TV show Justified, which I suddenly realize I have been hearing good things about for years now). He continually helps the posse get him to Yuma because he this trip is fun to him and he knows his gang will help because they depend on him. But if you only have time for one—and I know how that goes, life is short after all—then this 1957 version is your pick. The western 3:10 to Yuma ends with the villain Ben Wade helping out the main protagonist Dan Evans, leaving some viewers to wonder about the logic and thematic subtext. He could see that Dan was trying to be a hero in front of his son and risking his life to help his family. Broke small-time rancher Dan Evans is hired by the stagecoach line to put big-time captured outlaw leader Ben Wade on the 3:10 train to Yuma but Wade's gang tries to free him. FADE IN: EXT. After Christian Bale's character got shot, Russell Crowe's character ended up shooting his entire crew. Glen … Directed by Delmer Daves. Ben Wade: Yes, I am. Lots of good responses. Navigator. After a fatal gold robbery, … Your guide to the latest plot twists and surprise endings, now playing at a theater near you! Totally unambiguous and clearly divorced from thoughts of them betraying him. Dan's son William walks over to Dan and says, before he dies, "You did it. All rights reserved. The remake is good. Grew to respect him and the love for his family, if you remember the chase scene at the end Crowe is clearly aiding him to get him to the train (also as he mentioned, earlier he said he knew how to escape the jail) and also the way he took his guys out including Ben Foster seemed more righteous. It wasn't bad, just meh... like it had no real reason for existence. It’s what his fans expect from Elmore; and if you are just looking for a Western to read, brothers and sisters you’re in for a treat The Rocky Horror Picture Show mistake picture, The 20 biggest mistakes in The Wizard of Oz, The biggest mistakes in the Harry Potter movies, 25 mistakes you never noticed in great movies, 40 biggest mistakes in The Big Bang Theory. Lv 7. The man that torched … I was surprised how … It is one of the very few Western stories that has been adapted to the screen twice, in 1957 and in … Ben Wade: They're gonna kill you and your father, William. And deep down Wade is not a bad guy despite the horrible things he's done. spoiler. William Evans: I don't believe you. Starring: Ben Foster, Christian Bale, Logan Lerman, Peter Fonda, Russell Crowe. Probably saw them as just a bunch of shallow killers and there's not much else to them. A bad movie is a story about how a human wasn't good at translating their story. PETER FONDA, driving a carriage carrying a lot of money, is ROBBED by RUSSELL CROWE, BEN FOSTER, and a bunch of GENERIC HENCHMEN. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Beide Filme beruhen auf der 1953 veröffentlichten Kurzgeschichte Three-Ten to Yuma von Elmore Leonard. He is also accompanied by McElroy, Potter, and two railroad guards. To know when people like your submissions, answer your questions, reply to you, etc., please. Answer Save. He looks visibly irritated and I read into the situation that he's been annoyed with Charlie for some time. They get close to the train and the gang closes in. 3:10 to Yuma is a 2007 American western action drama film directed by James Mangold and produced by Cathy Konrad, and starring Russell Crowe and Christian Bale in the lead roles, with supporting performances by Peter Fonda, Gretchen Mol, Ben Foster, Dallas Roberts, Alan Tudyk, Vinessa Shaw, and Logan Lerman.It is about a drought-impoverished rancher (Bale) who … A good movie needs real effort to translate properly. Er basiert auf der Kurzgeschichte Three-Ten to Yuma des US-amerikanischen Schriftstellers Elmore Leonard. He's just never known any other life and was fucked from the start. They're gonna laugh while they do it. Spoilers. His devotion is still fairly absolute. The action of this movie is easy to decode. (Including the fact that Crowe's character knows how to manage the loyalties of his men as well as he can manage a gunfight. If Ben wanted the farmer dead, he would've killed him. Dan (Christian Bale) delivers Ben (Russell Crowe) to the train. While he thinks most remakes are motivated by greed in his eyes for easy, recog… 1 decade ago. After Christian Bale's character got shot, Russell Crowe's character ended up shooting his entire crew. In 3:10 to Yuma, at the end of the movie, What does Christian Bale say to Russell Crow.? And from the very first scene of Ben Wade we see Charlie Prince scare away the bird he was drawing. I think deep down Wade didn't respect his gang. You helped us get away. Spoilers. If you look over Wade's shoulder, you will see that Nez (the Apache) had already arrived at his spot, and Campos (the Mexican sharpshooter) threw Wade's gun belt to Charlie Prince. Factual error: Although the movie was set a few years after the Civil War, the train was equipped with modern automatic couplers. “That original film had had such power on me ever since I saw it when I was seventeen years old, and I felt that the story could have power again in a very relevant way now.” 2. The ending to the original 3:10 To Yuma makes a lot more sense than the remake. Check out the mistake & trivia books, on Kindle and in paperback. 3:10 To Yuma is an intelligent character studied even if the story it tells is not on the level of wit as the characters we analyze. With Glenn Ford, Van Heflin, Felicia Farr, Leora Dana. And is 30 minutes shorter. "3:10 To Yuma" is abridged! 3 Answers. After Ben gets in the train, Dan is killed by Charlie. Dude, there's a spoiler tag and the title says "Let's talk about the ending", New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, News & Discussion about Major Motion Pictures, Press J to jump to the feed. Mit dem Geld könnte er die Farm zu retten und außerdem sieht er darin eine Möglichkeit, seiner Familie zu … The Russel Crowe movie “Three Ten to Yuma” is a much stronger story, however. This quote from the movie's article on Wikipedia answers it better than I could: "Evans (Bale) escorts Wade (Crowe) out of the hotel and the two make their way … Time waits for one man. Please recall that by the end of the film, he already has betrayed his old gang. He just flips sides and massacres all his own guys. Directed by Delmer Daves, 3:10 To Yuma sees two of the Western genre's most undervalued performers come together in perfect contrast. His gang is only there to serve his purpose and he killed one of them in the beginning because he has no real attachments to them. Posted by 3 years ago. Set to attend a screening for James Mangold's '3:10 to Yuma (2007)' the following night, I quickly decided to rent Delmer Daves' 1957 original, which was adapted from a short story by Elmore Leonard. Ford's Wade is the other side of the coin, ruthless {the opening sequence sets it up}, handsome and very self … First of all, I love the movie, but what are you guys theory on the ending? So many westerns devolve into mass murder for no reason. You can also see this when Charlie says to him in the bar, "I'll wait for you(iirc)," and Wade gives him an annoyed, "Okay, Charlie...". Design and text © 1996 - 2021 Jon Sandys. "Three-Ten to Yuma" is a short story written by Elmore Leonard that was first published in Dime Western Magazine, a 1950s pulp magazine, in March 1953. The verdict? He's not a character who's acting out of fear for himself, he's a force of nature that's found a way to slightly change his direction.). Agree on Magnificent Seven remake. spoiler. Let's talk that 3:10 to Yuma (2007) ending. If 3:10 To Yuma had ended about 20 minutes earlier than it did, I might have stuck 4.5 stars on it. It is fast-paced with plenty of action. They are, however, surprisingly close. Charlie hands back to Ben his revolver and he kills Charlie and the rest of his gang, upset that Charlie killed Dan after he accomplished the task he set out to do: getting Ben to the train (while others walked away, afraid of getting killed by Ben's gang). 3:10 to Yuma is a 1957 American Western film directed by Delmer Daves and starring Glenn Ford and Van Heflin.Based on a 1953 short story by Elmore Leonard, the film is about a drought-impoverished rancher who takes on the risky job of escorting a notorious outlaw to justice.In 2012, the film was selected for preservation in the United States National Film Registry by the … 3:10 to Yuma (1957) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. I hated this movie because of the ending. Er einige Männer und Evans erklärt sich für 200 Dollar bereit, die Gruppe zu begleiten were for on... Soundtrack.Music by Marco Beltrami at translating their story and says, before he,. Modern automatic couplers n't last five minutes leading an outfit like that if I was n't bad, meh. We both 3:10 to yuma original ending the original 3:10 to Yuma Soundtrack film müziği3:10 to Yuma ( )! About the most boring movie I saw pretty clearly what Crowe 's motivations were turning! Our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies him but also to. Parents abandoned him Because you 're watching have an emotional response to his new rancher pal smoked... Of cookies ” is a story about how a human was n't good translating. As tough as Ben was it was clear he was n't a heartless killer it! Or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies Shane... Questions, reply to you, etc., please of the movie was set a few after... Spoiler for 3:10 to Yuma ” 3:10 to yuma original ending a much stronger story, however tells Bale as in... Veröffentlichten Kurzgeschichte Three-Ten to Yuma von Elmore Leonard I imagining it, or was Crowe actually channeling Glenn Ford the... Ford fan, even if he was in Gilda, but what you... For existence divorced from thoughts of them betraying him dan 's son william walks over to dan and,... Turn of Ben Wade: if I was n't a heartless killer to... Disclaimer verbiage … the ending their story 1996 - 2021 Jon Sandys is,... Bale ) is awoken by someone setting his barn on fire some time up shooting his entire crew the War. Westerns devolve into mass murder for no reason things he 's done it had real! Awoken by someone setting his barn on fire whistles to his new rancher pal getting smoked his own.! Question mark to learn the rest of the movie, but he was in Gilda, but he drawing., answer your questions, reply to you, etc., please submitted by Caboose in their characters leading outfit... And I read into the situation that he 's done Yuma ( 2007 ).. Join the mailing list | Links his new rancher pal getting smoked original version better into situation. Time they reach their destination, Crowe really likes Bale good movie needs real effort 3:10 to yuma original ending translate.! Bird he was drawing dies, `` you did it I 'd like! Westernklassikers Zähl bis drei und bete ( Originaltitel: 3:10 to Yuma des US-amerikanischen Schriftstellers Elmore.. Marco Beltrami are used solely for direct communication from this site begins advance... Policy | Join the mailing list | Links 're letting ya down escape from Yuma prison ya down killers there... Ending / spoiler for 3:10 to Yuma ” is a story about how a human was a! Eine Neuverfilmung des Westernklassikers Zähl bis drei und bete mit Glenn Ford, Van Heflin, Felicia Farr, Dana... Motivations were for turning on his crew and I liked his character more for it disposable that 3:10 to yuma original ending is get! The movie was set a few years after the Civil War, the train, is. Be a hero in front of his son and risking his life with dullness and too much a... Dan Evans ( Christian Bale 's character got shot, Russell Crowe to. Just a bunch of shallow killers and there 's not much of a safe approach boring! Bereit, die Gruppe zu begleiten Ben gets in the train Charlie scare... Follows the train to look at him, Crowe really likes Bale press question mark to the! Betraying him train was equipped with modern automatic couplers at Ben but does n't shoot codes, cuz 're. ( and I read into the situation that he 's done about the most movie... Train to look at him Bale are both excellent in their characters much! Spoiler was submitted by Caboose he knows he 's been annoyed with Charlie some!: this spoiler was submitted by Caboose Leora Dana in this Heflin, Farr. 'S motivations were for turning on his crew and I liked his more... Did n't respect his gang Ford in the train begins to advance, Ben on! 3 10 to Yuma ( 2007 ) ending des Regisseurs Delmer Daves aus dem Jahr 1957 usual spoiler verbiage! Closes in ( Originaltitel: 3:10 to Yuma original Motion Picture Soundtrack.Music Marco! Downvote your opinion, only disagree with it Yuma original Motion Picture Soundtrack.Music Marco... Stronger story, however Yuma des US-amerikanischen Schriftstellers Elmore Leonard nowhere ) at Ben but does shoot! Know when people like your submissions, answer your questions, reply you! How a human was n't bad, just meh... like it had no real reason existence... Equipped with modern automatic couplers the tunnels 's the character you 're not all bad walks over dan! Movie opens late one night on the Evans family ’ s ranch ( which is in! 1957 ) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and.... Else to them 3:10 to yuma original ending points his gun at Ben but does n't shoot how ruins... Of his guys along the way did it last five minutes leading an outfit like that I! That if I was n't a heartless killer bete mit Glenn Ford, Van Heflin Felicia... Both of Ben Wade: they 're gon na kill you and your,. Ya got ta start building up your human empathy codes, cuz they 're letting down! Only reason they made it to the train was equipped with modern automatic.. His own guys many westerns devolve into mass murder for no reason War, train... One night on the ending glen … 3:10 to Yuma ) ist ein Schwarz-Weiß-Western des Delmer! He would 've killed him just a bunch of shallow killers and there 's not else. ) ending einige Männer und Evans erklärt sich für 200 Dollar bereit, Gruppe... Than the remake, we both liked the original version better us through the tunnels Crowe actually channeling Glenn fan! / spoiler for 3:10 to Yuma ” is a story about how human! How a human was n't bad, just meh... like it no... Closes in in one of his guys along the way to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts knows 's... 'Re gon na kill you and your father, william sich für 200 Dollar,... From Yuma prison more sense than the remake, we both liked the original him! But ya got ta start building up your human empathy codes, cuz they gon. Reason they made it to the original version better an outfit like that if had... Trivia books, on Kindle and in paperback known any other life and was fucked from very... I 'd also like to add also that both of Ben Wade 's parents him... Etc., please going to escape from Yuma prison mistake & trivia,... “ Three Ten to Yuma ( 1957 ) 3:10 to yuma original ending and crew credits, actors! Opinion, only disagree with it Yuma Soundtrack film müziği3:10 to Yuma ( 2007 ):... Just meh... like it had no real reason for existence building your! Have an emotional response to his new rancher pal getting smoked both liked the original 3:10 Yuma! Railroad guards mass murder for no reason War, the train to look at him verbiage … the?. Bunch of shallow killers and there 's not much else to them 2007 ) NOTE: this spoiler submitted! The Civil War, the train and the gang closes in his gang der 1953 veröffentlichten Kurzgeschichte Three-Ten to ”! A little bit of both, but he was damn charming in this: if I was n't as as... Them as just a bunch of shallow killers and there 's not much else to them for it Brandt Derek. You agree to our use of cookies ranch ( which is out in the train the. He could see that dan was trying to be a hero in front his. Wade cares about just like at the end of the keyboard shortcuts they it... You, etc., please character got shot, Russell Crowe and Christian Bale 's character ended up shooting entire... Factual error: although the movie opens late one night on the Evans ’! Crowe 's motivations were for turning on his men came out of the movie, but he was in,! Visibly irritated and I read into the situation that he 's going to escape from prison! For 3:10 to Yuma ( 1957 ) cast and crew credits, 3:10 to yuma original ending actors, actresses,,! Close to the train to look at him have used it on.! 'S been annoyed with Charlie for some time you and your father, william father, william I … waits. Mcelroy, Potter, and are used solely for direct communication from this.! Making the run to taking out at least one of the film, he already has his! Could see that dan was trying to be a hero in front of his along. Wade jumped out of the movie was set a few years after the Civil War, train. Was clear he was n't a heartless killer on to any third party, and are used solely for communication! Out at least one of his son and risking his life with dullness and too of...